Exclusive listing or multiple agents? What actually works when you sell your home
When you decide to sell your home, one of the first questions is: is it better to give the listing to one agent, or to work with several at the same time?
Many people’s instinct is that more agents means more visibility, more buyers, more chance of selling quickly. In practice it almost always works the other way around.
What happens when you work with multiple agents
A property listed with multiple agents appears on the portals several times, often with different prices, different photos and different descriptions. The buyer sees it repeated, wonders why nobody is buying it, and starts negotiating the price down — or dismisses it altogether.
None of the agents involved has a real incentive to invest time and resources in that property: if another agent sells it, the work done is wasted. The result is that everyone does the minimum, nobody does the maximum.
The seller, meanwhile, receives calls from multiple sources, does not know who is doing what, and struggles to understand where the sale actually stands.
What changes with an exclusive listing
With an exclusive listing, the agent knows that the work they do is their own work. It is worth preparing the property properly, taking care with the photos, writing an accurate listing, screening buyers and managing viewings attentively.
The seller has a single point of contact, who knows the situation from beginning to end and can be called at any time for a genuine update.
Communication is more orderly, the negotiation more manageable, and the risk of burning the property on the portals is much lower.
So how do you choose the right agent?
This is the real question. And the answer changes the order in which many sellers move.
The most common mistake is to ask several agents for a valuation and choose the one who proposes the highest price. This is a criterion that rewards those who inflate estimates to win the listing — and penalises those who work honestly.
The method that works is different: first you choose the agent, then you ask for the valuation.
To choose, it is worth visiting more than one. Not to compare prices, but to understand how they work: how they explain their method, whether they answer questions clearly, whether you feel free to ask anything without feeling judged or pressured. A good agent has no problem explaining how they arrive at an estimate, because they have the data to back it up.
Once you have chosen the agent, you ask that agent — and only that agent — for the valuation. If something does not convince you, ask for an explanation. If the explanation is not forthcoming, change agent — but before signing, not after months of the property sitting unsold.
The shared exclusive: a separate case
There is also an intermediate arrangement, known as a shared exclusive or MLS (Multiple Listing Service). The seller signs with a single agent — the lead agent — and incurs no additional cost compared to a standard listing: they pay one commission, to one point of contact.
How it works in practice: the lead agent manages all the documentation and lists the property on the portals, their own website, their window display and social media. The secondary agent lists it only on their own website and in their window. If the sale completes through the secondary agent, the seller’s commission goes to the lead agent, and the buyer’s commission goes to the secondary agent.
The lead agent, by placing themselves at the service of the seller, gives up part of their own commission in order to widen the search and sell more quickly. It often turns out, however, that this is not needed: the buyer arrives through the main portals first, if the listing is done well.
Want to know how much your property in Sanremo is worth?